Poor Skillers? What would you do?

Poor Skillers? What would you do?

I'm in the market for a new car I have a 12k loan at 3.9% and a trade in worth 5k but I'm expecting for them to only give me 2-4k on it. I also saved 5k cash. So I'm working with 20k or less.

Options:

1. Around $11,000 -A 2008 Toyota Yaris Hatchback-will be used so little to no warranty. I fit fairly inside it- I'm 6'1." Toyota is quality so I hope it'll last long, but lack of warranty scares me. Having to not use my savings is appealing.

2. Around $18,000 out the door- A 2010 KIA Soul. Brand new- full 5 yr +10yr power train warranty. Bigger car- More $$ on insurance probably. KIAs lose value quickly. I love the way it looks/drives. Might last longer than the Yaris (bc of warranty?)

Thanks in advance.
EDIT: Thank you all for your help. Well this post was in the queue while I car shopped. The Yaris' bumper was falling off and I couldn't fit in it. They gave me 4k for my trade in. I ended up getting the Kia Soul. Will update if anything breaks. haha.
whats the weed? and jack in the pulpit

whats the weed? and jack in the pulpit

Painting my walls.

Painting my walls.

Father Time

Father Time

Today’s harvest-  The weird year continues

Today’s harvest- The weird year continues

Decorating Questions

Decorating Questions

One of the best things in my yard…

One of the best things in my yard…